Productivity Research Conference  4th – 5th September 2025 Find out more

A diverse community of leading experts, policymakers and practitioners

The Institute’s key research themes are led by ten academic partners spread across the UK.

Working closely with policymakers

We’re a UK-wide research organisation exploring what productivity means for business

Businesses are crucial to solving the UK’s productivity problems.

Shadows and donuts: The work-from-home revolution and the performance of cities

In this article, we set out the relationships between the behavioural and spatial responses to working-from-home. The analytical framework centres explicitly on the choice of commuting frequency in light of technological shifts. It is the commuting frequency which is the key decision-making variable that endogenously reshapes the relationships between other spatial and non-spatial variables.

We find that optimal commuting frequency is positively related to the opportunity costs of less-than-continuous face-to-face interaction and inversely related to commuting costs. As well as a “donut effect” with growth in the suburbs and hinterlands around cities, our results also identify a “shadow effect” in smaller cities. The reason is that, somewhat counterintuitively, commuting frequency optimisation magnifies the benefits of working-from-home in larger cities because of a greater decrease in the burden of commuting. Our results imply enhanced productivity of larger cities over smaller cities, suggesting that the economic divergence between large cities and left-behind places is likely to persist.

This paper was updated in November 2024. The original 2022 paper is still available to read.

Themes

  • Geography & Place

Published

13/11/2024

Cite

S. Bond-Smith, P. McCann (2024) Shadows and donuts: The work-from-home revolution and the performance of cities . Working Paper No. 026, The Productivity Institute.
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.

For more information see our Privacy Policy